A normal SEO audit checks your site against a long list of good practice and reports everything it finds, from missing alt text to slow pages. A forensic SEO audit starts with a specific loss, such as a traffic drop, and works backwards through the evidence to find what caused it. The first gives you a to do list. The second gives you a diagnosis.
What a normal audit does
A normal audit is a health check. It crawls the site and flags issues: duplicate titles, broken links, thin pages, missing schema, slow loading. Each item is a reasonable thing to fix.
The trouble is priority. Fifty findings of equal weight tell you little about why traffic fell. If the real cause is one item on the list, you may fix thirty other things first. For a site that is healthy and just wants to improve, that is fine. For a site that is bleeding traffic, it wastes time.
What a forensic audit does
A forensic audit starts at the loss. It asks when traffic fell, which pages and queries lost, and what else changed at that moment. Then it tests causes against the evidence.
That means lining up the drop with Google update dates, site changes, redirects, indexing data and link data. It means checking Search Console reports for page indexing and manual action messages, and comparing the pages that lost with the ones that held. Anything that does not explain the drop is ranked low. Anything that does is ranked first.
The result is a short, ordered answer: this is the cause, here is the evidence, here is what to fix first. Our page on what a forensic SEO audit is sets out the full method.
Side by side
| Point | Normal audit | Forensic audit |
|---|---|---|
| Starting point | The whole site against a checklist | The loss and the date it started |
| Output | A long list of issues | A ranked cause and a recovery plan |
| Best for | Healthy sites improving | Sites that lost traffic |
| Priority | Often equal weight | By evidence of cause |
Which one do you need?
If traffic fell and you do not know why, you want the forensic route. If nothing is wrong and you want a tidy up, a normal audit will do. Our forensic SEO audit service is for the first case. To see what we would ask you for before starting, read what we need for an SEO triage.
FAQ
Questions owners ask us
Is a forensic audit only for sites that lost traffic?
Mostly. It is built for a specific failure: a drop, a penalty, a migration gone wrong or an index problem. If nothing has gone wrong and you want a general health check, a normal audit is the simpler fit.
Will a normal audit find the cause of my drop?
It may, but it often will not. A normal audit lists many issues of mixed importance, and the real cause can be buried among them. A forensic audit ranks everything by whether it explains the loss.
Get started